pet world
‘American Idol’: Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood come out on top as YOUR favorite winners ever

‘American Idol’: Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood come out on top as YOUR favorite winners ever [POLL RESULTS]

March 24, 2018 11:00AM


Surprising no one,   and   have topped  that asked you to name your favorite “” winner of all time. With 24% of the vote, Clarkson just narrowly beat out Underwood (23%) to earn the top spot. None of the other 13 champs even came close in our poll results. See all , and then sound off on your fave down in the comments section.


Clarkson was the first-ever “American Idol” winner back in 2002, while Underwood claimed victory a few years later for the reality TV show’s fourth season. As far as the Grammys are concerned, both ladies are winners as Clarkson took home two Grammys in 2005 (“Breakaway” and “Since U Been Gone”) and another in 2012 (“Stronger”), while Underwood has amassed a whopping seven trophies, including  of 2006.


Over the past 16 years, Clarkson released eight successful studio albums and can  on NBC’s rival singing series “The Voice.” Underwood, who’s released six studio albums since her victory in 2005, continues her  with shows in Tennessee on June 8 and Minnesota on August 2.


After Clarkson and Underwood, here is how the other 13 “American Idol” winners fared in our poll:  Trent Harmon (Season 15) is third place at 15%,  Nick Fradiani (Season 14) is fourth at 13%,  Scotty McCreery (Season 10) is fifth at 8%,  Taylor Hicks (Season 5) is sixth at 6%,  David Cook (Season 7) is seventh at 5%,  Phillip Phillips (Season 11) is eighth at 4%, and  Kris Allen (Season 8) is ninth at 2%. The other six winners all earned 0% of the vote.

Katherine Heigl Reacts to Alex and Izzie's Shocking 'Grey's Anatomy' Reunion
This is the man Kelly Clarkson accepted to become "New Daddy" for two kids
Kelly Clarkson takes a mighty fall, but still sticks the landing... moments before singing the National Anthem at the Indy 500
Kelly Clarkson reveals why she wants to leave 'The Voice' with Gwen Stefani: 'I'm pregnant! '
Kelly Clarkson Falls To The Floor After Anne Hathaway Recognizes ‘Since U Been Gone’ First
Too Suprised! This is the man Kelly Clarkson accepted to become 'New Daddy' for two kids!
Kelly Clarkson and Brett Eldredge Spark Dating Rumors After Chemistry-Filled Performance
Kelly Clarkson And Brandon Blackstock Step Out To Take Their Kids Out For Lunch In LA!
Kelly Clarkson reunites with original 'American Idol' judges to receive her star on Hollywood Walk of Fame
So moving! Kelly Clarkson burst into tears when kids of Brandon said, 'You're always our mother'!